With Mother‘s Day quickly approaching, many are thinking of ways to honor their mothers for the love, support, great modeling, understanding, empathy, validation, overall wonderful things that most mothers provide for their children. Mother‘s Day is one of the highest days for flower and card sales.
For many others, the approach of Mother‘s Day brings about anxiety, resentment, frustration, and a general dis-ease about what will turn out to be a day of doom and gloom. For these distressed souls, this day marks yet another reminder of the mother they wished they had but didn’t. It marks yet another reminder of how inauthentic they must be for this day, as they desperately try to find a card that is most suited for the person who birthed them. None on the shelf seem appropriate, so they choose the most generic so as not to feel bad for “not getting her something.”
As a therapist who specializes in working with the “unmothered daughter”, otherwise known as daughters of borderline mothers (as in borderline personality disorder), I often hear stories of psychologically absent or severely dysfunctional, if not downright abusive mothering experiences. These daughters often struggle with depression and anxiety as the “day of honoring mothers” approaches. Many have talked about fantasies they have about creating a line of Mother’s Day cards that appropriately acknowledge the “mothers” they have. Some have suggested cards with the following sentiments:
“Happy Mother’s Day…(inside) Thanks for donating your womb. Sorry for the inconvenience.”
“Happy Mother’s Day…(inside) Thanks for teaching me to trust no one…living alone is AWESOME!”
“Happy Mother’s Day…(inside) Thanks for not selling me to goat farmers even though I know you thought about it daily.”
“Happy Mother’s Day…(inside) I am so sorry I ruined your body. The good news is I ruined mine too, so now we can be twinsies!”
“Happy Mother’s Day…(inside) Thanks…umm…I think…”
I think you get the picture. The sentiments are often very dark and riddled with sarcasm and satire. Certainly not anything they would say to their mothers, within earshot anyway, but definitely something they wished they could say. So instead they live with the dark fantasy. A dark fantasy to which most other daughters cannot relate.
Nevertheless, daughters of borderline mothers regularly report feeling terrible that they have such dark feelings and thoughts about a day that should be a day of celebration, a day that most of the world seems to celebrate without reservation. They feel extremely awkward at family events that are built around the borderline matriarch and often wish they had the nerve to say “No thank you, I have other plans that day,” to invitations for the Mother’s Day gatherings.
It is hard to celebrate when the truth of the matter for these daughters is that their mothers were anything but loving, supportive, great role models, understanding, empathic, validating, or providing just plain good enough mothering that didn’t leave them feeling worthless and loathsome. Often, they turn this darkness inward, blaming themselves for being “bad” daughters for being unable to happily celebrate their mother on this special day. Forget the fact that their mothers really have not earned the sentiment beyond birthing them. Rather, these daughters do what they were trained to do. That is, they take responsibility for their mother’s bad behavior, poor choices, and overall dysfunctional and unhealthy mothering.
Mothers with Borderline Personality Disorder use rage and guilt to manipulate their children. They project everything they hate most about themselves onto their daughters, expecting their daughters to be perfect containers for their toxic poison. They train them to trust no one, especially their own inner voice. These mothers train their daughters to not only distrust their inner voice, but to vilify anyone who would try to get close enough to give them a different perspective that does not match their mothers. Thus these daughters often feel very isolated, very lonely, very misunderstood, and very confused…even among those closest to them (mates, friends, children). They often report that “no one really gets them” and that if they actually shared their darkest selves with others, the outcome would be exactly as their mothers told them…that no one will love them, care about them, believe them, or stick around. It is no wonder that this day of honor is so difficult for these unmothered daughters to authentically engage in.
Marion Woodman, a renowned Jungian analyst, who wrote extensively about issues with food and mothering experiences, talks about the idea that when women, who were raised by this particular kind of mother, try to confront their “mother issues,” they often gain weight, or matter. She talks about the idea that as one is shifting their perspective of their relationship with their “Mater” (latin for Mother), they can feel “mater less” or “matter less” and thus gain matter (weight) to ground their souls back into their bodies. Imagine a Mother’s Day card expressing appropriate sentiment for that!
One of the common themes among daughters of borderline mothers is the idea of feeling starved…starved for attention, affection, acceptance, acknowledgement, and attunement. This feeling typically translates into behaviors that can be very destructive, whether physically, financially, sexually, or psychologically.
Daughters of borderline mothers, with whom I have had the honor and privilege of joining in their healing journey, have shared how they go about starving themselves. Sometimes it is in the form of actually starving themselves of food, sometimes consciously, but usually unconsciously. They report that they can go hours without food before realizing how very hungry they are. They are not able to really track what happened throughout the day that caused them to overlook the fact that they needed to eat. Sometimes it is in the form of starving themselves of what is good for them, such as healthy food, healthy people, healthy spending behaviors, restful sleep, creative outlets. They share that they have no problem poisoning themselves with bad food, unhealthy people, lack of sleep, destructive spending habits, drugs and other addictive behaviors. They share that even though they don’t want the poison, they don’t know how to say no to it. So they say “yes” to the bad and “no” to the good.
These are the thoughts that plague them as Mother’s Day approaches. It is no wonder they feel conflicted about how to celebrate it.
If you are an unmothered daughter, know that you are not alone. There are others who share your plight. Perhaps you will see them standing next to you in the Mother’s Day card section, the day before Mother’s Day looking perplexed because every card they pick out just doesn’t work, and it isn’t because all the best ones have been picked through and purchased…it is because they, like you, put off the inevitable to the very last moment. They, like you, are hoping against hope that what’s left on the shelf will be all the generic cards left behind by those whose mothers can be celebrated with great honor, making the selection process less painful and obvious.
If you are an unmothered daughter and want this to be the last Mother’s Day for which you feel guilty and ashamed because you have decided that you want to explore and heal your mother wounds, then you have come to the right place.
I am passionate about working with unmothered daughters who want to develop a healthy inner mother model so that they can begin to mother themselves in a more loving, validating, supportive way. If are ready to begin this journey with someone who really “gets it”, please call (714-296-8052) or email me (DrMiller@DrReneeMiller.com) to schedule an appointment. Let this be the year that you choose to honor your inner mother, who wants only good things for her inner child, on Mother’s Day.